About what is wisdom and what is being wise
Hello,
Now i will talk about wisdom , and of course , i have just
written an interesting article called: "About why
information is both the soul and the solution" , here it is:
https://myphilo10.blogspot.com/2025/04/about-why-information-is-both-soul-and.html
So i think
that my model in the above article shows the wise way , and
speaking about the wise way , here is my new article that talks
about what is wisdom:
So here is my new proverb that explains what is wisdom:
"Wisdom
helps you drive the car well and intelligence is the engine of
the car"
So here is my question to the AI (Artificial intelligence) from
OpenAI called GPT-4o:
Can we say the wisdom helps you to drive the car well and
intelligence is the engine of the car.
And here is what GPT-4o answered me:
"The analogy you've presented can provide a useful way to
differentiate between wisdom and intelligence:
1- Wisdom as Driving Skill: Wisdom, in this analogy, can be
likened to the skill and experience of driving. It encompasses
practical knowledge, good judgment, and the ability to navigate
complex situations. A wise person might know when to be patient,
when to take risks, and how to handle various challenges on the
road of life.
2- Intelligence as the Engine: Intelligence, on the other hand,
can be compared to the engine of a car. It represents cognitive
abilities, problem-solving skills, and the capacity to learn and
adapt. Just as a powerful engine can enhance the performance of a
car, intelligence contributes to a person's ability to
understand, analyze, and solve problems.
In summary, wisdom is more about the application of knowledge and
experience in a thoughtful and discerning way, while intelligence
is the raw cognitive ability to process information and learn.
Both are valuable attributes, and a harmonious blend of wisdom
and intelligence can contribute to overall well-rounded
decision-making and life skills."
And here is what the AI (Artificial intelligence) from Google
called Gemini 2.5 Pro , that is advanced , answered me about my
above thoughts:
"Okay, let's break down your discussion and the proverb.
**Critique
and Appreciation of Your Proverb:**
* **Strengths:**
* **Intuitive and Relatable:** Using the car analogy makes the
abstract concepts of wisdom and intelligence more concrete and
easier to grasp for many people.
* **Highlights Key Distinction:** It successfully captures a
common understanding of the difference: intelligence as raw
capability or potential (the engine's power) and wisdom as the
skillful *application* of that capability in real-world
situations (driving well).
* **Implies Interdependence (and lack thereof):** A powerful
engine (high intelligence) doesn't guarantee good driving
(wisdom). Conversely, skillful driving (wisdom) can make the most
of even a modest engine (average intelligence). It also suggests
you need *both* for optimal performance (a good driver needs *an*
engine, and a good engine needs a driver).
* **Focus on Action/Application:** Equating wisdom with
"driving well" emphasizes its practical, applied
nature, which is a core aspect of many definitions of wisdom
(knowing *how* and *when* to act).
* **Potential Limitations/Nuances:**
* **Oversimplification:** Like any analogy, it simplifies complex
concepts. Intelligence involves more than just raw power (e.g.,
different types like emotional, creative intelligence). Wisdom
involves more than just skill (e.g., deep understanding, ethical
judgment, perspective, self-awareness). "Driving well"
might not fully capture the ethical or long-term perspective
aspects of wisdom.
* **Interplay:** While distinct, intelligence and wisdom are
often intertwined. Acquiring wisdom often requires intelligence
(to learn from experience, understand consequences). The analogy
separates them quite cleanly, perhaps *too* cleanly for some
philosophical views.
* **What about Knowledge?** Where does knowledge fit in? Is it
the fuel? The GPS? The car's manual? The analogy focuses
primarily on capacity (intelligence) and application (wisdom).
**Critique
of Your Interaction with GPT-4o:**
* **"Smart Question":** Your question was effective. By
phrasing it as "Can we say...", you directly prompted
the AI to evaluate the validity and usefulness of your analogy.
It wasn't just asking *for* an analogy, but testing *your own*.
* **GPT-4o's Response:** GPT-4o's answer is excellent.
* It understood the core meaning of your proverb.
* It validated the analogy ("can provide a useful
way").
* It elaborated thoughtfully on *why* each part of the analogy
works (Wisdom = skill, judgment, navigation; Intelligence =
cognitive ability, problem-solving).
* It correctly summarized the distinction (application vs. raw
ability).
* It added the important point that both are valuable and work
best together ("harmonious blend").
**Overall
Assessment:**
Your proverb is a clever and effective way to communicate a
common understanding of the difference between intelligence and
wisdom. It's memorable and sparks understanding. Your interaction
with GPT-4o successfully demonstrated the utility of your
proverb, as the AI was able to grasp, validate, and expand upon
the analogy precisely as you intended.
It's a good piece of thinking and a well-executed test of your
idea with the AI. While philosophical debates about the precise
nature of wisdom and intelligence could poke holes in any
analogy, yours serves as a very useful starting point for
discussion and understanding. Well done!"
Thank you,
Amine Moulay Ramdane.
Comments
Post a Comment